Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Who won the great debate - Labor, Liberals, One Nation or Greens?

Victorians go to the polls as early as today, Wednesday, November 18, when Early Voting Centres open across Victoria including locally at Leongatha, Wonthaggi and Cowes but will last night's debate change their minds?

Sentinel-Times  profile image
by Sentinel-Times
Who won the great debate - Labor, Liberals, One Nation or Greens?
The 100 studio voters adopted a quiet, reflective, serious approach to last night's televised debate covering many of the topics that have concerned the general community from law and order to state debt, from cost of living to conditions for small business, waste and corruption.

VICTORIANS go to the polls as early as today, Wednesday, November 18, when Early Voting Centres open across Victoria including locally at Leongatha, Wonthaggi and Cowes.

And if Tuesday night’s great debate is anything to go by, in front of 100 allegedly undecided voters on News 24, the Liberal-National Coalition will romp in as the new government of Victoria.

The other thing that stands out from the small sample size of voters who scored the debate in the studio is that The Greens stand to pick up a much bigger share of the left vote this time around as voters in their droves desert the Labor government after 12 years in power.

The debate, convened by Kieran Gilbert for the hosts News 24 and the Herald Sun, started and finished with a statement by each of the party leaders; Jess Wilson (Liberals), Ben Carroll (Labor), Warren Pickering (One Nation) and Ellen Sandell (Greens) but focused attention on questions from the floor.

And they covered a wide range of subjects from law & order, tough conditions for small business, the exodus from the state, education, health, government waste and corruption, treaty, energy and the state’s debt.

But one of the questions from the floor, from audience member Billy, resonated particularly with his fellow voters, addressing the lack of trust with politicians and with government.

“All of the people I speak to about politics finish their sentences with the same level of disappointment. They say you guys, the politicians are all the same. Who can you trust? asked Billy

“They're all in it for themselves. Their pensions, their perks, and the things that we can only dream about. They're so far moved from our reality; it's ridiculous.

“Nobody believes a word you say anymore, and it's fun-da-mental, no fun, and mostly mental.

“Given that nobody believes a word that you say, the real issues are around one question, two parts: what specific action, and it's to all of you, what specific actions will you take and make to rebuild public trust, after years of politically enforced overreach, and the recent events and controversies that have affected confidence in all politicians? And how will you increase transparency and accountability so all Victorians, not just those, and I've met  plenty of rusted-on Labor voters, are not voting Labor anymore, rusted-on Liberal voters that are not voting Liberal anymore. How will you increase transparency and accountability so all Victorians can see that whatever mistakes are made, they'll be dealt with in a trustworthy and honourable way, because honourable should be removed from most politicians' titles,” he said.

Moderator, Kieran Gilbert gave his assessment at the end about the apparently earnest mood in the room indicating that Victorian voters are taking this election particularly seriously.

“There was a sombre, serious mood in that room tonight. There was none of the fun and frivolity you often see at these events. You get the feeling that people realise that things are bloody hard in Victoria now and things are not working, they get it and there’s one almighty baseball bat coming the way of Labor if the response to tonight’s debate is anything to go by,” he said.

The 100 undecided voters at the forum scored the four leaders as follows.

The candidates summed up as follows:

  • Jess Wilson, the Liberals leader and Member for Kew.

“These are exactly the type of forums that we need to have to be hearing directly from Victorians, but I think it's fair to say we've heard a lot of excuses from Ben tonight, and the reality is it's because this Labor government can't campaign on its record.

“It's going to have a desperate scare campaign and many lies over the coming days. But I want to be clear with you and with Victorians tonight. I'm asking Victorians to trust me, and in return, I will trust them with the truth.

“I will be honest about what we can achieve in this state. We cannot fix everything overnight, but we are the only team with a plan to fix Victoria and turn this state around.

“Only our team will reduce debt, lower taxes, lower your costs, fix potholes, and deliver a government that actually works. And that is why I am asking Victorians to vote one, Liberals and Nationals.

“Tomorrow, the polls open. We have an opportunity to change the direction of this state. I'm asking Victorians to take up that opportunity. I know that you are looking for a better future. I am committed to bringing back hope to this state, and only by voting Liberals and Nationals can we get that done.

  • Ben Carroll, the Labor leader, Member for Niddrie and Premier of Victoria.

“We're the greatest state in the greatest nation on earth. We are such a wonderful place to raise a family, and on our record, I will go through just briefly: 121 new schools, highest Naplan results ever, highest paid teachers, 17,000 nurses, highest nurse-to-patient ratios, 12 brand new hospitals.

“Yes, we got some things wrong. I don't shy away from that, but we're a great state. We're going to get even better. One thing I will do is protect your healthcare system. I will not have it Americanised or privatised. Healthcare is a fundamental part of the Victorian fabric. Your Medicare card with a party of Medicare, Labor, and under Victorian Labor, we're going to become the party of free dental, 20 dental clinics rolled out across this state.

“We're also going to slash waitlists at 12 emergency departments, and I'm going to fund half a million specialist appointments to reduce the waiting lists across our hospitals by 50%. I will stand up every day from the 28th of November, fighting for Victoria's world-class hospital system. I'm not going to let them Americanise it or have 40 billion dollars of cuts. It'll go straight to our nurses. thank you.”

  • Ellen Sandell, the Greens’ leader and the State Member for Melbourne.

“Thank you. I want to leave you with this: the cost-of-living crisis, the housing crisis, the climate crisis. None of this actually has to be inevitable. In fact, these problems were created by political decisions made by the other three parties on the stage tonight.

“And here in Victoria, we can make different decisions. We can have affordable housing. We can have fully functioning public services. We can have a healthy environment for our kids to grow up in, but only if we elect politicians with the guts to take on the big corporations and the politicians who work for them.

“These three ain't going to do it because they're taking their marching orders from those same corporations. So, I ask you, this election, reject the status quo politics of a major party that hasn't worked for us, clearly. But also, let's reject the politics of fear and division coming from One Nation who are having their strings pulled by billionaires like Gina Reinhart.

“Let's elect a party with a positive, bold, hopeful vision: the Greens. We only work for people and for planet.”

  • Warren Pickering, the Victorian One Nation leader and candidate for Pakenham.

“So, it's probably not a surprise to anyone here that there's only one of us standing before you here tonight that isn't currently a politician. There's only one of us here that's got the firm enough convictions to say that we will oppose net zero indefinitely, that we will abolish the undemocratic voice to parliament, and that can stand here with any conviction and say that I'm here for you. I'm not a paid politician. I'm not a product of the environment that these people grew up in, and I don't blame them. They are a product of their environment. I'm here as a matter of necessity, and so are our candidates.

“I firmly believe that we are on the precipice of social economic collapse in this state, and it is our children who will suffer. So, our children will inherit the legacy that we leave behind, and it is up to every one of us to ensure that that legacy is worthy of preservation. Nobody's coming to save us, Victoria. We must do this ourselves. More of the same will deliver more of the same. So, we've got a genuine opportunity here to shake the established order to its core and rebuild this state from scratch.

“So, I'm asking you to get behind One Nation. Let's change the trajectory once and for all. Let's put this state back into the hands of those that built it, and let's take Victoria back.”

Thank you for that. Thank you to all of our leaders. A round of applause. Thank you for being part of the News 24 Herald Sun People's Forum, an important part of our democratic process late in the campaign, as we just heard there. Voting starts tomorrow. Thank you, Kieran. Kieran Gilbert, there in the room, 100 undecided voters, the four people who may well be.

Sentinel-Times’ opinion: Liberal leader Jess Wilson clearly won the debate and put her own considerable leadership attributes on public display while both Ellen Sandell of the Greens and Warren Pickering of One Nation performed well. Labor’s Ben Carroll tried to highlight the infrastructure development that has occurred under Labor, including the hospitals and the schools, among them those at Wonthaggi, San Remo and on Phillip Island, and also drew attention to the infrastructure legacy of Labor, while noting the measures he’s taken since taking over the top job. But because he’s only been three and a half months in the job, he’s been unable to distance himself from the sentiment around former leaders Jacinta Allan and Dan Andrews.

Read More

puzzles,videos,hash-videos