Council backflip over Murray Street pedestrian crossing
Bass Coast Shire councillors have voted for a second time to defer a final decision on a proposed pedestrian crossing in Murray Street, Wonthaggi with continued concerns from local traders about the impact on local businesses and traffic congestion.
THE FUTURE of a proposed pedestrian crossing in Murray Street, Wonthaggi, remains undecided after Bass Coast Shire councillors voted for a second time to defer a final decision on the project amid concerns about the impact on local businesses and traffic congestion.
After initially voting to reject the crossing at this month's council meeting a final decision was deferred until December after a lengthy discussion about whether a crossing with flashing lights opposite Aldi supermarket would be a better alternative.
The proposed crossing has already attracted strong opposition from Murray Street traders who have raised concerns about traffic congestion, reduced parking and the potential impact on nearby businesses.
They claim a pedestrian crossing would lead to the loss of seven car parking spaces at the eastern end of Murray Street costing traders upwards of $300,000 annually.
Community members have expressed differing views about pedestrian safety along Murray Street. Highlighting the difficulties faced by people using mobility scooters at uneven crossings Wonthaggi resident Heather Reynolds said she believed a push-button crossing would provide a safer arrangement by allowing pedestrians to activate the crossing when needed while giving motorists time to move through.
"It is very dangerous,” she said.
Another Wonthaggi resident, Scott Morris, supported the plan.
"The cars go pretty fast through there, and it'd be great for people to get across the road," he said. Local resident Cathy said improved pedestrian access would allow people to get across Murray Street safely.
“I would be grateful if we can get across without getting hit crossing the road.”
Mitchell House Centre Manager Ben Cavender said he would welcome a pedestrian crossing in Murray Street opposite the popular community centre.
“I think it would be hugely beneficial for the community members that use our centre here at Mitchell House. We have a high number of elderly people that use our space, and that would allow for safer access to our centre.”
Addressing this month’s council meeting Bass Coast Shire Mayor Cr Brett Tessari said he understood the concerns being raised by traders and believed councillors needed to properly consider their position before committing to construction.
"My concerns are the traders' concerns,” said Cr Tessari.
“They have genuine concerns that it's going to affect their business. I just want the council and councillors to appreciate that they genuinely are concerned, and whether it's right or wrong, time will tell, so let's listen to those concerns."
Asked about the possibility of installing traffic lights Cr Tessari described the prospect of two sets of traffic lights close together as potentially problematic.
"A nightmare, I would imagine," he said.
"Let's have a look at what might work better than just putting a crossing there because we've got some funding for it. I'm not sure lights would go that well. I'd rather see the crossing move further down Murray Street," he said.
Councillor Meg Edwards questioned whether proceeding with the project because grant funding was available was necessarily the most prudent decision.
“Broader examination of pedestrian safety and traffic management at the Bass Highway intersection could deliver greater benefits,” said Cr Edwards.
Councillor Tim O’Brien said the recommended location best addressed the safety and convenience needs of pedestrians travelling along McKenzie Street and those crossing near the eastern end of Murray Street.
Councillor Jan Thompson supported the original proposal, saying she had personally assessed the recommended and alternative locations. “As a person with a disability I find the proposed location considerably easier to cross,” she said.
The project would be fully funded through the Transport Accident Commission's Safer Local Roads and Streets Program, with the total cost expected to be $212,000.
Council was advised there was insufficient time remaining in the funding program to scope, design and deliver a crossing at another location. Despite the funding concerns, councillors ultimately supported deferring a final decision for a second time to allow for further consideration of possible alternatives and the impact on local traders.
Councillor Ron Bauer said additional time would allow council to investigate whether another practical location could satisfy community expectations saying the aim was not necessarily to reject the recommended location, but to ensure all reasonable alternatives had been considered before council made its final decision.